This pie is old school delicious. Yes, more pie…per my promise of a recipe a week for the whole year. This is my mom’s bastardized version of a Betty Crocker recipe and made gluten free with my favorite crust. It has no gelatin for you gel haters! I make it with the lesser amount of sugar in the filling but you can more than double it if you are a sweet freak. I have never met a man who didn’t love it, well…maybe one. My friend Russel doesn’t care for anything with lemons. But his wife Claire adores lemon so this pie is for her and my mom…(It’s Mother’s Day after all!) and my brother Christopher who often requests this pie when he is in town.
If I have them, I always use Meyer lemons for this recipe. Your pie will have a really delicate flavor – so light I sometimes call it lemon cloud pie! Don’t worry; regular lemons work just fine. It can be difficult to find Meyer lemons and pricey too.
I have never gotten my mom to admit it but I am positive she added extra egg whites to her meringue. Her pie was towering with the white fluffy stuff unlike my nearly level pie made with just three whites. It is up to you how impressive you want your dessert to look. But if you have company you might want to go for the big bang of a four- five egg white meringue topping for maximum wow power
My mom added the touch of corn syrup to replace some of the reduced out sugar and because it makes the texture of this pie creamier and more delicate. Don’t make this pie on a very humid day or the meringue will weep and bead on the top. It will taste fine but the look will suffer from the humidity. My slice picture shows some of that beading; it started to get humid that day and my pie still tasted fantastic even with the slight beading issue.
Store any leftover pie in the fridge. It doesn’t keep more than two days but frankly none of it ever lasts more than two days.
Mom’s Lemon Meringue Pie
1 c plus 2 tbsp brown rice flour mix (at bottom of recipe) [King Arthur plain mix]
2 tbsp sweet rice flour
1 Tbps. granulated sugar
½ tsp xanthan gum
¼ tsp salt
6 Tbps. cold butter cut into 6 chunks
1 lg egg
2 tsp fresh orange or lemon juice
Spray 9 inch metal pie pan with cooking spray, dust with white rice flour.
Mix dry ingredients in bowl of stand electric mixer. Add butter and mix until crumbly and resembling coarse meal. Add egg and juice. Mix until it comes together into big chunks. Shape into a ball with your hands. Put it on a crust sized piece of wax paper (14 x 14 inches more or less), flatten the crust ball some; put on top of it another piece of wax paper and chill it all in your fridge 15-20 minutes. Then roll it out and line a 9 inch pie pan with it. Make sure you get the middle nice and thin; this crust can be tough to get the center as thin as the edges. Prick it all over with a fork to keep it from bubbling out and bake the empty crust at 375 for 10-12 minutes until light brown. Let cool.
1/3 to ¾ cup sugar
1/3 plus 1 tbsp. corn starch
1 ½ cup water
3 eggs, separated; yolks for filling, save whites for meringue
1-2 tsp. lemon zest
½ cup fresh lemon juice
2-3 tbsp. clear corn syrup
3 tbsp. butter cut in small chunks
Start oven heating to 400 degrees for browning the topped pie.
Mix the sugar and corn starch in a heavy bottomed medium sized saucepan. Add the water, stirring. Heat until it boils, stirring constantly, boil one minute, take off heat. Beat yolks briefly in a small mixing bowl, then add the hot stuff slowly to it; half the hot mixture, stirring constantly. Then dump it all back into the saucepan, bring to a boil, stir like a crazy person so it doesn’t scorch. Boil 1 minute at medium heat. Remove from heat, stir in the lemon juice and zest and then stir in the butter. Let it melt as you stir. Glug in some corn syrup. Pour the hot lemon filling into the pie crust. Top while still hot with the meringue you just beat up. Make sure you get the meringue all the way across the top and along every single edge. No cracks, no gaps. Bake it 10-11 minutes until light brown. Cool to room temperature and then chill for 2-6 hours. Slice and serve.
The three egg whites (or 4-5)
¼ tsp. cream of tarter
6 tbsp. granulated sugar (or 8-10 tbsp.)
Beat the whites and the cream of tarter until it is past the foamy stage, add the sugar half a tbsp. at a time beating on high until the whites are stiff and glossy. This will take several minutes.
If you add one or two extra egg whites add another ¼ tsp. cream of tarter and add 2 tbsp. sugar for each extra white.
Brown Rice Flour Mix (Same as King Arthur All purpose blend)
2 c brown rice flour
2/3 c potato starch
1/3 c tapioca flour
Originally posted March 2015, slightly revised for this posting.